Borrowed Confidence

Hi {{first_name}}

Imagine you're sitting at the boardroom table.

The discussion has moved to something you should have a view on. Everyone else seems clear on where they stand. You're still working it out.

Instead of saying that, you offer something. It sounds confident enough. The moment passes.

But you caught it. You noticed that wasn't your best thinking. It was a performance, and the distance from what you said to what you actually thought stays with you for the rest of the day.

Most leaders I work with describe some version of this. That room doesn't feel like a place where uncertainty is welcome. It feels like a stage where you're expected to have the answers, and anything less than certainty gets noticed.

So you perform. You speak before you've finished thinking. You project assurance you don't feel. And over time, you stop noticing you're doing it, because the act becomes automatic. The restructure you greenlit last quarter, the hire you approved without enough challenge, the strategy you endorsed while the room was waiting — all made on borrowed confidence rather than genuine conviction.

The cost compounds quietly. You stop saying "I need more time" or "I'm not sure yet" because honesty doesn't seem to get rewarded. And the gap between who you are in that chair and who you really are widens, week by week.

I've coached senior leaders for over a decade, and this pattern comes up in almost every conversation. The specific setting changes but the experience doesn't: capable, accomplished people who sense the boardroom is somewhere they have to earn their place, every single time.

That gap — external composure, internal uncertainty — is where most of my work begins. And where this newsletter lives, three times a week.

This week, three questions worth sitting with:

  1. When did you last say "I don't know" in a meeting, and mean it?

  2. What would change if honesty got rewarded as much as certainty?

  3. Who in your professional life knows what leadership actually feels like for you, not just what it looks like?

No right answers. Just worth noticing. Reply with whichever one landed — I read every response.

On Wednesday: why your best people have stopped telling you the truth.

Until then,

Gavin

Keep Reading